Sunday, 28 June 2009

Go, tetropters, go! (tetropters III)

In my last post on tetropter flight I tried to find some kind of proof that the way I imagined tetropters to fly is valid. Just to make certain everyone knows what tetropters are about I will provide two rough sketches of what tetropters look like:


A tetropter on the verge of being snapped up by a tetrapterate

A few examples of tetropters in flight

I turned to the world of 'micro air vehicles' for proof, but had to end the post with a question, as I could not find solid proof that a similar flight mechanism had indeed been invented.

Luckily, I can now report that there was indeed such a flying vehicle: the Mentor, and it flew in 2002! I emailed Roy Kornbluh (see the previous post), and he was kind enough to confirm that each of the Mentor's four wings clapped against both of its neighbours. Moreover, he directed me to a website with footage of the vehicle in flight. If you want to see it at its original place, you can find it here.

But you can also simply admire it here:



So the radial flight principle has been proven!

That does not mean that tetropters must exist on other planets. But my hypothesis is that they could, and that their mode of flying makes sense depending on what you start with. Perhaps ancestry is the simpleanswer to the question what determines whether evolution produces radial or bilateral flying body plans. Animals with bilateral symmetry that take to the air will probably end up with bilateral wings. All animal groups that evolved flight on Earth (insects, pterosaurs, bats and birds) started with a bilateral body plan in the first place. But if animals such as starfishes had gone for a more active mode of life, and had made it to land as well, perhaps their descendants would have made it into the air. If so, they would have started with a radial body plan. If evolution had taken this course, perhaps there would be animals with radial flight on Earth right now. For now, it's just machines.

Sunday, 21 June 2009

More on tetropter flight (Tetropters II)

All flying animals on Earth have bilateral symmetry. They can have two or four wings, but wings only come in pairs on Earth. Not so on Furaha, where tetropters have radial symmetry. I discussed them before on this blog. On Earth animals such as starfishes have radial symmetry: each of their five arms is like the others, and there is no left and right, nor is there a front or back. There are tops and bottoms though. Tetropters are similar: each of their four wings sticks out from the central body at a 90 degree interval from the previous or the next one, much as the blades of a helicopter stick out from its central axis. The similarity with a helicopter stops right there: helicopters are classified as 'rotary wing' aircraft, meaning the entire wing assembly rotates. Tetropters, being biological in nature, do not exhibit complete rotation.

Yes, yes, I know that flagellae do rotate, but I meant larger structures. I also know that a complete animal can rotate, but I was referring to part of an animal rotating completely in relation to the rest of the body and ending up with all body parts in the same position as before the rotation.

So the tetropter's wing beat to and fro, and up and down, and the wings rotate and change shape while they do so. Does this result in a believable animal? I thought so, but others might need convincing (hi Lewis!). So I started looking for proof.

But first, a few words on 'clap and fling'. The flight of insects is rather different from that of birds, and in part that has to do with their small size. Air appears more 'syrupy' at such small scales., which apparently changes aerodynamics profoundly. In larger animals air streams along lifing surfaces, and the stream has to be 'attached' to the surface. Not so in very small organisms, where things such as 'vortices' play a role.

Many insects use a mechanism called 'clap and fling' to increase lift: their wings, or pairs of wings, on the upstroke meet above their backs where they clap together. Before being pulled down they are rotated so their front ends are drawn apart while the trailing edges stay together. This apparently sucks air in between the wings, which promotes lift. Do not expect me to explain it, as the mathematics are way beyond me - I just accept it.


Click to enlarge

The above diagram shows the principles of clap and fling. It is the simplest I could find, and therefore probably too simple.

Back to the tetropter. When I first doodled them, some 10 years ago, I started thinking about the mechanics of radial wing designs, and I thought that a similar mechanism might work well. The thing is that an insect wing has only one clap in its movement cycle, but a tetropter wing can have two: it can clap against its neighbour in the clockwise direction, and half a cycle later it cn clap against its neighbour in the counterclockwise position. If one clap is good, surely two must be better? Based on that idea the tetropter flight took shape, and here it is:



I admit the animation is rather simple; the animal is depicted as a simple sphere, and instead of deforming during the clap the wings are shown as if they can move through one another. Still, you should get the idea. I am a bit proud of the design, as it might just be a feasible design that life on Earth hasn't come up with.

Now, proving that this could work might be difficult. Luckily for me, there is a lot of research being devoted to 'micro air vehicles'. No doubt we wil see tiny flying robots used for surveillance purposes in the future -that seems to be the drive behind it-. Some of these tiny aerial vehicles are fixed-wing aircraft, but quite a few use moving wings: such devices are called ornithopters, and, as with anything, there are websites devoted to them. Here is a nice ornithopter site.

A design that seems to be gaining popularity is the 'X-wing', meaning that the craft has two wings sticking out ate each side, placed one above the other. When these wings beat, the upper wing moves down and meets the lower wing moving up, so the two clap together. Mechanics is mimicking biology here, and as usual evolution has produced amazing designs. Some examples of such flapping ornithopters follow.


This one shows a rather large (for a micro air vehicle) ornithopter by Yuzuke Takahashi, but its size helps to show how the wings move. The original can be seen on YouTube here.



And now DelFly from the University of Delft in the Netherlands. Here is their website, showing various designs (unfortunately, their latest designs do not seem to be featured on the site).

The interesting thing about this design is that it allows the craft not only to fly horizontally but also to hover, simply by assuming a vertical position. So we have hovering flight making good use of a clap and fling mechanisms. Insects have been doing that for hundreds of millions of years...

Unfortunately for the tetropter, the designs I found are all based on bilateral symmetry. Surely someone has thought to extend the clap and fling mechanisms along tetropter lines? I asked the DelFly people, and they pointed me in the directioon of a small ornithopter jointly developed in California (Menlo Park) and at the University of Toronto, labeled 'Mentor', that was supposed to use a radial design with four wings. Rather frustratingly it proved difficult to find out much about it. I did find a picture though on one website:

The text states that this is Roy Kornbluh from the Stanford Research Institute holding a robot capable of sustained flight. The device seems rather large to fly under its own power. Perhaps it is a large-scale model? More importantly, is its design indeed a radial one, or is it an X-wing like the ones shown above?

I wish I knew; a video of an ornithopter with a radial design would prove that the tetropter flight plan is more than just theoretically possible. Let's see if I can find out more...

Sunday, 14 June 2009

Socotra

Last time I showed two sketches of odd plants, and asked whether they were believable or not. There was only one taker: Rodlox; he thought both were believable. I had secretly hoped that someone would have considered both plants completely alien, as in reality only one of them was an invention of mine. The second one was drawn from a photograph of a plant right here on Earth. To prove that, here it is:

Click to enlarge (holds for the other images as well)

If you do not see the resemblance, that may be because I presented it as a mirror image of the photograph. The plant grows on the archipelago of Socotra, out in the Indian Ocean. The story of this island group is one of relative isolation, so there was little influx of mainland Asian or African species. Instead, evolution ran its own course here, and as always the results betray common biological principles, but recombined time and again to result in new and intriguing forms. "Infinite diversity in infinite combinations", I am tempted to write, but that quote is from Star Trek's Mr Spock. I have no idea what the text writers meant by putting those words in his mouth, but I doubt they referred to evolutionary biology (a pity, as the phrase seems very apt to use in a evolutionary setting).

I first heard of Socotra about a year ago when I read a book on plants, and one tiny photograph made me very curious. A few months ago, I came across more photographs on the internet, and now Socotra seems to be everywhere. That may be just me, though.

I have shown photographs of Terran creatures on this blog before, usually as an example of some biological principle. This time is different, as I will show Socotran plants only for what they represent: odd-looking plants, that may well be found in Furaha large deserts. And indeed, rather similar life forms can be found there.

After all, the usual plant shape with lots of leaves and thin stems results in an enormous surface to volume ratio. While this is good to catch lots of light, it does nothing to prevent evaporation. If water is precious, the little there is may not be allowed to escape into thin air, but must be stored. Few or no leaves, a rotund shape and anti-evaporation measures are all called for, and that is exactly what you see.

Some more examples follow. I will show some taken from two sources so I can acknowledge the photographers.

A first series is from Jan van Dorpe; the photographs can be found on Flickr:



A second series is from Abdelkrim Belkilani and Loic Marchat; their site has many more images of Socotra.


I think that I would like to visit Socotra; then again, Madagascar has its share of wonders too, and I haven't been there either.

First things first though... Life is hectic at the moment, which explains the hiatus in posting. But I am thinking about some intriguing themes for this blog:
- the 'clap-and-fling' mechanism is a known mechanisms to improve the lifting capabilitilties of flying insects. I borrowed it for Furahan Tetropters, and have started to think that this might make them superior flyers; now, to make that convincing will take some work...
- what are toes for, precisely, and why are the front legs in mammals not connected to the vertebral column by a solid weight0brearing connection, but -susually- by muscles instead?
:

Sunday, 31 May 2009

A question for the audience: not alien enough, or too unlikely to be true?

There are only a limited number of people designing and illustrating their own worlds and life forms, and in quite a few cases their designs seem to converge on either similar biological designs, or on the work of earlier designers. In the first case 'convergence makes sense, as that is what evolutionary biology does as well. The second type makes less sense, if you ask me... Anyway, an example of convergence is that, if you wish to move quickly through water, streamlining is inescapable. There are many more constraints like that, and to be believable a design has too look biologically plausible.

But isn't that too limiting? Where are the limits in such designs? 'Cephalisation' is a recurrent trend in evolution, meaning animals tend to have heads, i.e., various organs and functions are clustered together near the front: food intake, sense organs and processing ability seem to form a package that comes with a discount if you buy all of them together. Can you do away with a head altogether?

How about limbs? I have discussed limbs and locomotion often enough in this blog and on my site that I will not repeat all that again: gravity and energy expenditure limit what you can do with legs. But there can be more or less than four. The current main group of Furahan terrestrial animals happens to have six, but rusps are quite common too, and some Giant Rusps, with 20 to 30 legs, give the hexapods a run for their money. And that does not even count the octapods or the five-limbed raptorial jumping spidrids.

Still, I do get the criticism sometimes that my organisms are too 'Earthy'. In part that is my own fault for having Furaha look so much like Earth. Perhaps I have shown too many parochial organisms. There are certainly some oddities in my sketchbooks that have not made it to the site.

One such follows: here are some arboreal predators; you might expect some lighting-quick brachiating animals jumping and swinging through the canopy, and these indeed exist (they're just not shown on the site either...). Instead, these are sneaky ambush-type predators, hidden in the canopy, preying on animals making their way over the forest floor. The one of the left might be descended from hexapodal stock, but the one on the right has a body plan all its own. As you can see, the predators can grip branches and can spear animals passing underneath. If that doesn't kill them, their poison will, and rather quickly to (it had better, or else the wounded animal will bound away and succumb somewhere beyond the predator's reach.

Click to enlarge

But is this believable? Is such an essentially passive and sessile life style workable? Wouldn't prey learn to spot it and simply choose another path? Isn't this an evolutionary dead end if the prey has good senses and is highly mobile? Personally, I am not certain, and so this particular type of predator is even more imaginary than the rest of them: I haven't decided whether to raise it to the rank of actual Furahan species or to condemn it to continual 'uncreation'.

I would like to ask the readers of this blog to comment on two sketches of plants (or mixomorphs, as the case might be). I did have a specific environment in mind, but would like to hear your opinion. Both are 1-3 meters in heigth. Species A is round with branches coming out of whorls on its body/stem, and species B is flattened sideways, and seems to sit on the ground rather than grow from it as species A does.

So, are these not alien enough, or are they too unlikely to be believable?
This is species A


And this is species B

Sunday, 24 May 2009

A forest in 'Dan Dare'

Sorry, but I haven't really got time to write a blog this week. Instead, I will just provide something to look at: it is half a page from the late-fifties British comics magazine the Eagle, and specifically a page of 'Dan Dare', a stiff upper lipped hero. The page is from the story 'The man from nowehere, and finds the multispecies group just after crash landing on a planet. The drawings were by Frank Hampson, and -at least initially- much time was spent designing characters, props, etc. Many the stories are set in space or in a high-tech setting, so there aren't that many plants and animals. There are various humanoid aliens, though. Just have a look at this website. More information can be found on Wikipedia. The stories are being republished and can easily by found through Amazon. But here is a forest scene. I guess that many of the details may not hacve an immediate biological meaning, but I admit that I do not design all background organisms anything in intricate detail either. I like the designs though. I think that I could have designed something very similar to he umbrella-shaped branches in the background of the third panel on top. I partiuclarly like the root or stem supporting it. Nice, isn't it?
Click to enlarge

Tuesday, 19 May 2009

Furaha in the Cheltenham Science Festival

The Cheltenham Science Festival in the UK runs from June 2 to June 7 and is held in, well, Cheltenham. What you might like to know is that Furaha will feature briefly in it. On Thursday 4 June at 18:00 hrs Lewis Dartnell will speak about 'Alien evolution'. Lewis is an astrobiology researcher at University College in London. Here is his website. He has written a book on astrobiology: Life in the Universe, a Beginner's Guide. Here is the text from the website regarding the talk:

"How might the human body evolve if forced to live with the weightlessness of space stations or in habitats on the Moon or Mars? And how might Darwin’s natural selection have played-out for the plants and animals we may one day encounter in other worlds? Lewis Dartnell shows you the real face of ET and explores the fascinating realm where evolutionary biology meets exotic worlds!"

And what part of that means is that he will show a few images of Furahan life as examples of evolutionary routes not taken on Earth. If you are in the area, why not have a look?

Sunday, 17 May 2009

Alien plants

Every now and again I search the net for anything interesting about speculative biology. Typing in 'alien' is not a good idea, as there appear to be untold numbers of sites concerning little green or gray men with very big eyes who apparently visit Earth to abduct people either to perform unspeakable experiments or, failing that, to make farmers' lives miserably by doodling abstract forms in their grain fields.

Entering something like 'exozoology' or 'exobotany' is better but yields very few hits. So, with some trepidation I typed in 'alien plants', expecting the usual sites of Earth plants that cause trouble on a part of a planet where they do not belong. But this time I was directed to a message of someone wondering about the reality of a video. Some more research revealed it had been made by a company doing among others computer graphics; here is the link of the company, but I could not find the video on the site, so you may be wasting your time there.

The video was still present on YouTube, and I copied it (it is at the bottom of this post) as a mpg file. Here is the YouTube link for those who wish to see it in its YouTube surroundings.

By and large, I like it. The image seems to be a composite or real life footage with CG effects, which works quite well to convince the viewer that the scenery looks real. I looked at it a few times and started to think about what you see, and what all the effects are for.

What you mostly see is that these plants move. Obviously, all plants move, in the sense of growing and being moved by the wind, but these of their own accord on the timescale of animal movements. Some Terran plants do that as well: many seeds are dispersed by the sudden release of stored energy, either elastic or driven by turgor (turgor is the pressure inside plant cells; they push against the cell walls, giving the ensemble stiffness, like a tough balloon or a tire).

(from Wikipedia)

The above picture shows a Venus flytrap; it moves, and so do quite a few other plants. But the plants on this short segment, without any title, move differently. Their movements can be repeated and some are fairly complex. I wonder what the machinery behind the movement is? Contractile cells, i.e. muscle cells? A special kind of boosted turgor?

Moving plants are not that uncommon in science fiction; just think of John Wyndham's 'The Triffids'. Triffids could not just walk about on stumpy rots, but had nasty tentacle-like thingies to lash out and blind people, and they communicated by making sound.

This is the cover of a Dutch translation I read as a child in 1967 (the cover is by Rien Poortvliet! -for those to whom that means something-). Triffids were well thought out, and there seemed to be a sinister reasoning behind their make-up.

Click to enlarge

The same even holds for the big carnivorous plant in 'The little shop of horrors; after a sessile phase in which it depends on mobile forms to bring it food ('Fee me, Seymour!') it moves about on its own.

In many other cases having the ability to move does not make much sense for a plant. In science fiction, of which speculative biology is a part, there should ideally be a reason for any characteristic; at the least some 'techobabble' is expected. The video shown below does not display any reasons for movement. I would like to know more, but this is just a short clip of life somewhere. If you were to see a clip of some Terran field with flowers, you would not be told why flowers exist, or that they may be seasonal, or how the proceration of plants intermingles with the life of insects. So I am inclined to just enjoy it, and perhaps to start thinking about the reason for some of the movements.

But there is one thing I am uncomfortable with: many of the plants seem to have eyes. That raises the question why they would have any. Eyes are apparently not difficult to evolve, and there are an amazing number of ways to design eyes (an excellent book is: Animal Eyes by MF Land & D-E Nilsson). There are eyes that merely tell their owner from which direction light is coming, while other eyes have exquisite resolution and/or sensitivity, like ours or an octopus'. But you do not find such pinnacles of high-tech eye design on a mollusk spending its life stuck to a rock. They would need a big brain to do something with the visual information, and even if they had that, what would a clam do with the knowledge that a dangerous predator is coming its way? Run away? In fact, good vision does not stand on its own. It only pays to have high-quality vision if the resulting information can be processed and put to good use. All these things must evolve hand in hand, so to speak.

So I prefer to think that the eye-like organs in the video are not eyes at all. What we see is an organ with a shutter moving quickly across its surface every now and then. That does not mean it must be an eye. Perhap the working of this organ depends on a sensitive membrane that needs to be kept moist and clean. If only I could think of a function that does make sense...